Buy History in Practice 2nd Edition (Hodder Arnold Publication) 2 by Ludmilla Jordanova (ISBN: ) from Amazon’s Book Store. Everyday low. Is history a subject that primarily appropriates its theory from other disciplines? In this lively and readable study, Ludmilla Jordanova examines the many. Review of Ludmilla Jordanova’s History in Practice and Truth in Historical Writing By Abbey Mikha 1 What is truth? Can truth truly set a historian and a human.
|Published (Last):||19 January 2008|
|PDF File Size:||9.49 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||2.53 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
It looks at history as an academic discipline but also engages with the use of historical ideas in the wider world.
Historical research is about collecting information, sorting it, and writing it into a compelling explanation that accounts for the partial nature of our evidence, and our partiality as researchers.
For example science and biology all speak of natural truth but history on the other hand has so many times jordnaova to be false. Refresh and try again. If a just God were writing the history of the world what would that history be?
Richard LeComte rated it liked it Apr 27, Jordanova believes that the goal of completeness is simply histlry especially since as the world of scholarship expands there is more and more to read, but she does not consider that if the historian tries to be as truthful as possible, then another historian can take the information the first one has researched, and continue the research from there with the goal of completeness and truth in mind.
How do the ways historians divide up their subject affect their work, and how have these divisions changed over the years? A lot of what Jordanova outlines and advocates for sounds like common sense to me already. From this it follows that the practice of history should be identified not only with the archive, which has been the usual focus of reflections by historians on their craft from Mabillon to Marwick but with the written results of histkry and their audiences.
You could not be signed in. Her examples are helpful and well chosen and overall this rela Lets be honest, no one ludmillz likes historiography. Preview — History in Practice by Ludmilla Jordanova. And what is the nature of the links be How do the ways historians divide up their subject affect their work, and how have these divisions changed over the years?
Jordanova should have strived to be clearer in her explanations and she should not have used jargon when common language would have been more appropriate. Want to Read Currently Reading Read.
Carlos Aguirre and Paulo Drinot. Can truth truly set a historian and a human free? Here Jordanova, as the guest curator of a highly successful and intellectually stimulating exhibition on ‘Scientific and Medical Portraits ‘ at the National Portrait Gallery last Summerwrites from a rare position as an academic historian with direct experience of the challenges of presenting historical arguments to the general public 4. Historical writing is always an unfinished work in progress, but if the ideal of truth is always in the mind of the writer then his or her work is a stepping- stone towards truth.
No trivia ludmiloa quizzes yet.
Why have certain fields, such as women’s history and Black history, generated such intense debate about their value and validity? Whilst one might have anticipated her plea for the integration of the study of visual culture into historical practice, less expected is her impassioned defence of Clio’s current Cinderella, economic history.
In the eyes of such scholars, this development is merely an updated version of the, to their mind, equally misguided attempt by the cliometricians of the s to turn history into a social science of the past staffed by computer-bound teamworkers in white coats.
History in Practice 2nd edition: Ludmilla Jordanova: Bloomsbury Academic
Even more pertinent are the presuppositions and results of the MORI poll which was undertaken to assist the authors of Power of Place in their work 8. When most people think of genocide, the atrocities of Hitler immediately spring to mind. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. I disagree with her on this matter because there have been thousands of times throughout history when historians have emphasised reliability and yet were dishonest and truly selfish in trying to project their truth instead of the real truth of the world and history.
In this context, Jordanova’s observation that the past presented by museums ‘is highly refined, in the manner of processed foods, [which] renders both the original materials and the means by which they have been processed relatively invisible’ p. Jordanova does not touch on such controversial issues and she does not defend anyone that history has not already shielded. Just to take the former, it can mean: What ordinary people felt and what they tried to accomplish was regarded as insignificant, not even worth regarding as part of history, but the truth is that real history is history from below because it is the untold story of humanity.
Civility and Science in Seventeenth-century EnglandChicago, Sign In Forgot password?
My library Help Advanced Book Search. However, if you are a bit of a history buff you will surely find something worthwhile. Not only does this mean that [heritage] practcie will need to consider audio, visual and tactile interpretation techniques, but they will also have to think about how to engage visitors’ emotions, if they are to make a lasting impression, and create true value. The poll, in particular, substantiates Jordanova’s emphasis on the centrality of the role of state, as key funder of museums and archives, in public history, on the one hand, and on the fact that: History in Practice Ludmilla Jordanova No preview available – A good introduction to what academic history is and what academic historians do.
Of particular value in this book is Jordanova’s principled eclecticism and her openness to widely different approaches and methods.
History in Practice
It is, to my mind, a very significant contribution to current debates about the nature of history in offering an account which is simultaneously rooted in practice and engaged with theoretical debates. She wants to know the truth, but she does not want to be held accountable historyy it parctice she does not want to be the one to hold people completely accountable for it.
Deborah rated it liked it Apr 12, Open Preview See a Problem? Sign in via your Institution Sign in.